It was strictly a coincidence that our ticketing system (running on Paciolan software) and the Colorado Rockies’ World Series ticket sales (running on Paciolan) failed on the same morning.
In our case, technicians at the University of Tennessee’s Tickets Unlimited had been trying all night to install a new router in order to add new capabilities to the system which serves not only the Thompson-Boling Arena but the Knoxville Civic Auditorium and Coliseum, Tennessee and Bijou Theatres, Broadway in Knoxville, Knoxville Symphony Orchestra, Knoxville Opera, and us, the Clarence Brown Theatre at the University of Tennessee. Something went wrong, and they had to put the old router back on line. Meanwhile, we had to put a few patrons’ sales on hold until the system was restored.
In the Rockies’ case, the online portion of the ticketing system was overwhelmed with demand for Rockies World Series home games. The system crashed, and less than 500 of about 60,000 seats were sold on Monday, Oct. 22. According to the Rocky Mountain News,
The Colorado Rockies will try again to sell World Series tickets through their Web site starting on Tuesday at noon.
Spokesman Jay Alves said tonight that the failure of Monday’s ticket sales happened because the system was brought down today by an “external malicious attack.”
…
The Rockies opted for an online sale of fewer than 20,000 tickets for each of the games in Denver, saying it was the fairest method for fans.
Paciolan Inc., which provides ticketing networks to Major League Baseball and 700 college and professional teams, was “amazed and overwhelmed” when it was flooded by 8.5 million hits for tickets in 90 minutes, Alves said.
…
Meanwhile, technicians at Irvine, Calif.-based Paciolan scrambled to fix the glitch.
“Right now, we have a couple dozen engineers that are in the back office trying to figure out exactly what the technical problems are,” Shaw Taylor, spokesman for Paciolan, said late this morning.
The head of the firm took responsibility for the crash, saying it affected the company’s entire North American system.
“This is not the Rockies’ fault in any way whatsoever,” said Paciolan CEO Dave Butler said. “We are working hard to address it.”
Paciolan’s Web site says the firm’s network systems sold 120 million tickets last year — about one-quarter of all live event tickets sold in the U.S.
Understandably, those wishing to buy tickets to the Rockies’ first-ever appearance in the World Series are not very happy. YourHub (Denver) notes that this isn’t the first time that Paciolan’s internet sales have raised hackles before:
In a blog posting titled “eVenue Can Suck My B***” ( link) on Oct. 28, 2004, author sbutler summed up his frustration with the site after being denied tickets to a football game:
“Throwing together some stopgap, Band-Aid, horrible solution is never a good idea in the long run. If you haven’t sat down and thought seriously hard about the planning of your program, then someone needs to take away your keyboard and replace it with a whiteboard and markers.”
Alexa.com, a site that monitors Web sites reliability and global rank, listed evenue.net as “Very Slow (83% of sites are faster).” ( link)
Secondary ticket marketplace StubHub late Monday night had Saturday and Sunday Colorado home game tickets for sale at prices ranging from $712 to $17800 each.
It’s still a developing story, but a cartoonist for the Rocky Mountain News has already captured the feeling of fans in Denver:

Boston Red Sox officials are preparing for the first game of the World Series on Wednesday night. Their ticket sales (via Tickets.com) had already concluded without incident. Tickets.com uses a different approach to high volume ticket sales, including a “virtual waiting room” in which those wishing to purchase tickets sit until the system is ready to process their ticket requests. The virtual waiting room automatically checks the status at regular intervals, so there is no need for potential buyers to keep logging onto the web pages to try to buy the tickets. It has been used successfully for several years for a number of venues — for example, they process over 600,000 tickets on the first day of single ticket sales for the Chicago Cubs each year.
The World Series ticket problem rippled into other areas – ticketing at other Denver facilities also served by Paciolan was knocked out, and in fact Paciolan says their entire nationwide network was affected, as noted in this email from CEO Dave Butler:
Dear Roger,
Paciolan is currently experiencing technical difficulties with all Internet applications. We believe this is due to unprecedented response to the World Series onsale this morning. We are working to resolve this issue as quickly as possible. We are also investigating the possibility of a large-scale denial of service attack.
We know that this has impacted your business negatively and apologize for this. We will communicate with you later in the day after we resolve the current issues and determine the root cause.
Sincerely,
Dave Butler
CEO, Paciolan
Actually, I haven’t been able to tell that our Internet sales were actually down at all, but some in other area were hurt. I suppose we’re lucky that Hannah Montana didn’t bring us down a few weeks ago. We were without our ticketing system for an hour or two this morning; the Rockies’s sales were delayed a least a day, and much goodwill was lost.
It is not surprising that there was a lot of demand from Colorado fans for their first-ever World Series tickets, but I believe it unreasonable to think that that the demand was “unprecedented”. Everytime my Cubs get into the playoffs they gobble up every ticket in sight within an hour or two. (In the other team’s town too!!!) Rockies’ ticket demand was heavy, and whether it was due to faulty design of the ticket processing system or to a lack of controls to mitigate a malicious attack, the system just didn’t work.
These two breakdowns were a coincidence. That we must take a fresh look at our ticketing partners is not.